Let’s start our offseason look by examining what the Yankees have in terms of position players under contract and free agents heading into the offseason.
Backup- John Ryan Murphy
On the 40-man- Austin Romine, Gary Sanchez
This is not an area the Yankees will need to spend any time worrying about. McCann had a nice season for the Yankees. Murphy hit enough that you wonder if he could play another position occasionally to get his bat in the lineup more. Sanchez raked at AAA and is tearing up the AFL. Romine is nothing more than filler at this point and may get DFA’ed to clear a 40-man spot.
Starter- Mark Teixeira
Backup- Dustin Ackley
On the 40-man- Greg Bird
I am not going to list Bird as the backup to Teixeira because I can’t see the Yankees doing that in 2016. If Teixeira is healthy, he is starting and Bird is probably in the minors to start the season with the way things are right now. If, and this is a huge if, the Yankees can clear some of their DH logjam, maybe Bird could squeeze into the picture, but right now I don’t see it. Regardless, Bird is clearly taking over at first after 2016, and the Yankees won’t sweat this position either
Starter- Steven Drew- FREE AGENT
Backup- Dustin Ackley
On the 40-man- Jose Pirela, Rob Refsnyder
I really can’t imagine the Yankees bringing Drew back, so this position is up for grabs. While everyone enjoyed the Ackley/Refsnyder platoon down the stretch, it is important to remember that the Yankees did that in September with a swollen roster. In the regular season, the Yankees typically carry only 3-4 players on the bench and platooning becomes much harder. I assume they will bring Ackley back as he can play 1st, 2nd, and the outfield, and Refsnyder has plenty of potential. Pirela could have value as a super-utility guy, but he hasn’t played short in a few years and neither Ackley or Refnsyder has either.
Starter- Didi Gregrorious
Backup- Brendan Ryan (UPDATE Ryan has exercised his $1-million player option)
On the 40-man- nothing
Didi’s 2nd half showed a lot of promise and the Yankees will rest easy knowing they have him this offseason.
Assuming they exercise the option on Ryan, he will serve as a backup here and around the infield. The problem is, if Ryan is on the bench it will be harder to have both Ackley and Refsnyder on the team.
Starter- Chase Headley
Backup- Brendan Ryan
On the 40-man- nothing
This is an area the Yankees could consider making a change. Headley had a bad season with the bat and surprisingly with the glove. The problem is, the Yankees would need to find a replacement outside the organization (Ackley has never played 3b btw) and trade Headley. That’s probably not going to happen, so I expect Headley back to third and the Yankees hoping he rebounds.
Starter- Brett Gardner
Backup- Chris Young-FREE AGENT, Dustin Ackley
On the 40-man- Slade Heathcott, Mason Williams
If the Yankees are going to make a big trade and get a little less left-handed, this is the guy they trade. A reasonable contract and solid production give him a lot of value. The problem is, the Yankees and their fans really like him. If they don’t trade him, the outfield will be the same in 2016 as it was in 2015. That could be a good or bad thing.
I think the Yankees will try to keep Young, but he may be looking for a starting spot. Heathcott and Williams both looked good in limited time and can both play all three spots, but both are lefties, so getting a righty bat in the mix is a to do item.
Starter- Jacoby Ellsbury
Backup- Young, Heathcott, Williams
Let’s get this out of the way, you are not trading Ellsbury. To start he has a no-trade clause. In addition, the market for guys who are owed over $100-million and put up an OPS of .663 last year is “small”. The Yankees need him to play more like he did in 2014 next year.
Starter- Carlos Beltran
Backup- Young, Heathcott, Williams, Ackley
And you are not trading Beltran. He isn’t going to waive his no-trade, and he played well last year. After A-Rod and Teixeira, he was their best hitter. Yes, he really isn’t a right fielder anymore. That’s a problem with DH currently taken, but the good news is that this is the last year of Beltran’s time in the Bronx. Assuming Judge is ready, he takes over in right in 2017.
Backup- Everyone else
This is the biggest quandary for the Yankees, what to do about A-Rod. Fact, they don’t make the playoffs last year without him. Fact, he had his best season since 2009. Fact, he is going to be 41. So what do you do about all of that? Do you close your eyes and hope he can somehow repeat his 2015 performance?
The gutsy move would be for the Yankees to write him a check and say goodbye. The amount is not as outrageous as it once was- $42-mllion or a few million less than they paid Kei Igawa or Carl Pavano. It is certainly an amount they could afford. They could tell A-Rod that they will release him or trade him, and it is up to him to accept the trade. Find a team willing to take him for a bag of balls and a couple of million in salary relief and move on. That would free up the roster logjam and let you do things like Beltran at DH with another person in right, or Teixeira at 1b and Bird on the roster as DH.
I don’t think they will go that way because the projection systems say he can still hit around the league average. Steamer forecasts him to put up a line of .240/.334/.413 with 24 homers. The average DH hit .259/.333/.439 last year, so he wouldn’t be that far off. I wonder if anyone will ask Brian Cashman point-blank if A-Rod will be back next year. Someone should.
Tomorrow we look at the pitchers.