If I were a Hall of Fame voter, these would be my choices for the upcoming ballot. I am going to rank them alphabetically first and then explain.
Jeff Bagwell was one of the best hitters in the NL during his career. He was an on base machine and won the Rookie of the Year, Gold Glove, and MVP.
Craig Biggio was one of the best second basemen in the game and an offensive force.
I will bunch the next two guys together- Bonds and Clemens. They used PED’s, but it is silly to pretend that they were the only ones. I have long advocated that we put the whole 1990’s to present era in a separate wing of the Hall, or put PED admission and suspicion on the plaque itself. I also can’t get too worked up about their PED use, while the Hall has racists like Cap Anson and Ty Cobb among its membership. Clemens and Bonds were the best pitcher and hitter in the game for a large part of their careers and they deserve to be in the Hall.
I will bunch the next two guys together as well. From the late 90’s to the mid-2000’s if you had to win one game, who would you want to start? Pick RJ, pick Pedro, I can’t argue with either choice. They were the two best in the game. While RJ has the better stats, and 300 wins, Pedro has a 154 ERA+ which is simply amazing. They are both no-brainers for me.
Mike Mussina will set off protests, but here’s an interesting exercise adopted from this really good article:
Which pitcher is the best?
Pitcher A: 270-153, 3.68 ERA, 3,562.2 IP, 2,813 SO
Pitcher B: 216-146, 3.46 ERA, 3,261 IP, 3,116 SO
Pitcher C: 194-126, 3.46 ERA, 2,898.2 IP, 2,668 SO
Pitcher D: 213-155, 3.33 ERA, 3,473 IP, 3,084 SO
Pitcher E: 211-144, 3.28 ERA, 3,256.1 IP, 2,397 SO
The guy with the most wins, Pitcher A, is Mike Mussina. The guy with the lowest ERA, Pitcher E, is Kevin Brown. The remaining three pitchers are (B,C,D) Schilling, David Cone and Smoltz. Using WAR, Mussina is 5th on this year’s ballot behind Bonds, Clemens, Johnson and Pedro. Using JAWS, he 7th behind the same four plus Bagwell and Schilling. Yet, Schilling and Mussina are stuck in the 20% range of the vote while Smoltz has a very good chance of getting into the Hall in his first year.
Piazza may have been the best offensive catcher in baseball history. He deserves to be in the Hall.
Schilling is in the Jackass Hall of Fame already, so why not baseball’s? I kid, I kid, but the guy was one of the best pitchers in the game and amazing in the postseason, he deserves it.
Trammell gets my vote here because of Hall of Fame rules. He is about to come off the ballot and I believe he deserves to be in. I could easily have voted for some other guys, but to me it will be awful if he falls off the ballot like Jack Morris did. Trammell’s numbers are not overly impressive until you remember that he was a shortstop and other than Ripken, shortstops didn’t put up hitting numbers like that.
There are plenty of other guys I could make a case for, but rules allow only 10, so those are mine. How about yours?