Main

October 30, 2007

Pena Back As A Coach

I listened to a lot of the Mattingly and Girardi conference calls today and these were the big points I got out of them.

1- Mattingly isn't mad, bitter anything. He is going to try and become a manager elsewhere, but I think he will come back to Yankee Stadium whenver invited. (phew)

2- Pena is back as a coach for the Yankees. His role hasn't been determined and the Yankees are trying right now to lock up other coaches (contracts for current coaches expire tomorrow) no word on which ones.

3- Girardi said all the right things and really didn't give much else. Apparently, there will be a "formal" introduction Thursday at the Stadium.

Lastly, the Daily News reported that Mariano and his agent were in Tampa negotiating with the Yankees today.

The Final A-Rod Post

Some ancient cultures punished people who had committed great crimes by literally erasing their names from history.  They became nameless entities or a symbol was used in place of their name and I can think of no greater punishment than that for A-Rod.  So, from now on, when I comment about A-Rod, I will do so with the following symbol:  "<".  Why "<" instead of "$"?  Well "$" is seemingly appropriate, but I think "<" as in less than, is a better way to describe he who shall now be nameless.  Anyway, I don't think I will be using the < that often, because unless he plays the Yankees, I have no reason to ever discuss him again and I could not be happier about that. 
 
But, before we say goodbye to <, I thought it would be fun to look at something he said, or something he wrote on his blog last year.  As a note to all athletes, don't blog unless you mean it.  Here it is:
 
"After we were eliminated on Saturday, the media asked me a lot of questions regarding my future in New York -- whether I want to leave, or if I will be traded, etc. I will tell you what I told them: I am 100 percent committed to being a Yankee now and in the future. I don't want to play anywhere else. I never have (and never will) run away from the responsibility I have to this team. I believe I am part of the solution to winning a championship here. I want to finish my career in New York."
 
Here's the link, though I imagine Boras&Co will be smart enough to take this down quickly because how you go from that to opting out 10 days early and not even talking to the Yankees is unfathomable.   
 
As for my own feelings about <'s departure, the stat guy in me is distraught.  Replacing that production is going to be very hard.  But, the rest of me is actually pretty happy.  < was too much of the story in New York, I spent too much time worrying about him and defending him and I can't help but agree with Andy who thinks that <'s personality detracts from whatever team he plays for.  As much as I hate Scott Boras, I don't think that announcement Sunday night was done without <'s approval.  I am not saying the Yankees will be better next year without him, but I have a hunch that <'s departure is not going to be as bad as we think.
 
And let's talk about replacements.  There seems to be three ways to go:
 
1- Sign/trade for another third baseman or let Betemit play the position.
 
2- Move Cano from 2nd to 3rd and find another second baseman.
 
3- Move Jeter from SS to 3rd and find another shortstop.
 
Of the three possibilities, #2 is the one I like the least.  Cano has transformed himself into a pretty good secondbaseman.  He turns a nice double play and his bat (.306/.353/.488) is one of the best at his position. (AL 2B hit .284/.339/.416)  If he moves to third, his bat is still good, but not as good when compared to the position. (AL 3B hit .280/.348/.456).  I think you leave Cano where he is right now.
 
I don't like the idea of Betemit everyday, I think he is perfect for the bench, so I wouldn't mess with that.  The third baseman available in free agency do not impress me.  I know Mike Lowell just won the MVP of the World Series, but he is going to be 34 and he had a OPS split of .993/.767 home and away.  I think he will get a big contract, and I hope the Yankees don't give it to him.
 
Aaron Boone is available.  Just kidding, wanted to see if you were still paying attention.   But, that's my point, there isn't much out there.
 
Trades may be a better way to go and while many will say go get Cabrera from the Marlins.  He scares me.  He is bigger everytime I see him and he makes Manny Ramirez look like a model citizen.  No, I would check and see if two injured guys might be available on the cheap, Joe Crede and Eric Chavez.   
 
Neither one of these guys is going to come close to replacing the offensive production the Yankees lost at third, but they are both much better defensively than <.  You are taking a risk since they both are coming off of surgery, but that is why I am betting you could get them cheaply.  Chavez to me presents the most intriguing possibility because I wonder if you could spin off Jason Giambi in a deal for him?
 
Let me explain, Chavez is signed through 2010 with a club option for 2011 at total of $37 million if he is bought out after 2010.  Giambi is due $27 million for 2008 plus a buyout of his 2009 option.  Billy Beane is one of the best GM's in the business and I can't imagine he likes the idea of 12% of his payroll for the next three years going to a guy coming off of two surgeries.  Giambi was incredibly popular in Oakland and I bet he would go back for a last hurrah.  If the Yankees paid the $5 million fee for the option and sent something to Oakland, would Beane bite?  He would be freed from the Giambi obligation at the end of the season and have money to spend.  The Yankees could take the risk on Chavez and get rid of Giambi at the same time which would free up the DH spot for Matsui. I think it is worth a phone call.
 
As for Crede, Josh Fields hit 23 HR's in his absence last year and Crede will be a free agent after 2008.  Would Chicago be willing to give him up for a mid-level prospect since they might want to go with Fields?  Again, worth a phone call.
 
My last idea is more generalized, but what about moving Jeter over to third?  Cal Ripken did it, so why not Jeter?  Despite the gold gloves, he has never been a great shortstop and his arm is good enough for the longer throws.  At some point, I think the Yankees will have to make this move anyway, so what about doing it now?
 
There are obviously a lot of other ways to go and we will discuss them more in the future, but from now on it will be about filling the opening at third base and not about <. 

October 29, 2007

That Was Fast

Check out this report in the Journal News tonight.  That is a great spot for them both and I hope they have a lot of success.   I just hope A-Rod doesn't join them.

And, if you were wondering, the Yankees are not scheduled to play the Dodgers next season.  But they will come to New York May 29th to play the Mets.  Of course the NL does come to Yankee Stadium for the All-Star Game.

UPDATE 12:35am- Joe Torre was just on Letterman and David asked him about going to LA.  Torre's response was:  "There has been a time or two when something that's been in the newspaper hasn't been true.  There is nothing to any of it, so far."  (Keep in mind, they usually film these shows around 5-6pm. 

With that, I am going to bed. 

Boras on 1050AM In New York At 5:20pm Today

If you are not in New York, follow this link if you are interested in listening.  I will be picking up my daughter, so please post a comment if you hear anything good.

Another Crazy Day In Yankeeland

Say this for the Yankees, they might not be playing, but they are certainly making news.  Fresh off the A-Rod debacle, the Yankees have apparently offered the managerial job to Joe Girardi. 

These are not George's Yankees anymore, George would have given the job to Mattingly in a second.  Not saying that's a bad thing, but it is a notable one.

And, what can we expect from Girardi?  We know he will work hard, but his usage of young pitchers makes me pause.  Let's look at the 2006 Marlins staff.

Dontrelle Willis was the ace. He was 25 and his first six starts of the year by pitch count were: 107, 111, 113, 106, 92, 120.  Of his 34 starts, only five were less than 100 pitches and at one point he made seven-straight starts of more than 115 pitches.  To be fair to Girardi, he never let him go past 125 pitches, but it was a lot.

And it wasn't just Willis.  Jason Johnson didn't become a starter until May and once he was he got used. He was 41st overall in baseball at an average of 99.297, just ahead of Andy Pettite.  Anibal Sanchez wasn't far behind (48th/98.8235) just ahead of Randy Johnson. 

None of this means it isn't correctable.  Just as the "Joba Rules" were put in place this year, Cashman can come up with some Kennedy and Phil rules to protect them.  I hope he does and if so, I think this will be a pretty good choice.  Joe Torre always talked about how great a manager Girardi would be and in his one year of work, he was very, very good. 

The sad part of all of this is Don Mattingly.  What happens with him now?  I am afraid he might take this rejection personally.  He clearly wanted the job and he didn't get it.  Reports say he has turned down an offer to coach and I would expect him to show up as a coach in LA if Joe Torre really does head there to manage.  But, the big question is next season when they close Yankee Stadium, will Mattingly choose to be a part of that?  It would be awful if he didn't and I hope the Yankees do everything they can to make sure he is there.

I was originally going with an A-Rod post today, but that will wait for tomorrow.  If you haven't read it, check out Buster Olney's take on ESPN or Mike Vaccaro's in the Post.  Better yet, take a listen to Peter Gammons on ESPN Radio.  (I can't link to it and you need to be an insider to get it, but it is worth a little digging to find.) I can't recall ever hearing Gammons come down on a player like that.  Cynics will say it's his Red Sox bias showing through, but I think he is genuinely upset. 

October 28, 2007

Goodbye Alex

Alex Rodriguez has opted out of his deal with the Yankees. Scott Boras offered this gem of a quote:

"Alex's decision was one based on not knowing what his closer, his catcher and one of his statured pitchers was going to do.  He really didn't want to make any decisions until he knew what they were doing." 

Never mind that he had 10 days until after the World Series to do this and the Yankees were preparing an offer and had requested a face-to-face meeting with him.  Clearly, this guy wanted out and I hope the Yankees accommodate him and let him leave.  I will never understand Alex, I don't know if it's the money that drives him but I now fully expect him to end up in the same situation as he did in Texas. And, the timing of this move leads you to conclude that he really wanted to stick it to Steinbrenner.  So be it, the 2008 Yankees just got a lot weaker, but as I said a week ago, this is a huge opportunity for the club to take a step back toin order to take a leap forward. 

I don't want to clog up the blog with anymore on this tonight, this space should go to the Red Sox, they've earned it and they look like they will have something happy to talk about, but I will be back tomorrow with more on this.   

October 23, 2007

Two Must-Reads

While I continue my plans to dismantle the Yankees (joking) I thought I would point out two very interesting articles on the net today.

The first is a very different take on the Joe Torre decision.  I like Heyman and I think he is usually very plugged into the Yankees' situation since he used to cover them for Newsday, but I hope he is wrong here.  At this point, it is a pointless argument, but Heyman's piece is really about the first one I have seen that didn't praise Joe for his choice and therefore I pointed it out. 

The second is far more important.   Let me say right off the bat before the Boston fans rise up against me that I don't think there is a conspiracy here, but like Rosenthal concludes, this is a terrible job by baseball.  Bad job by me that I hadn't realized before that Mitchell was a member of the Red Sox organization, serving on the board.  He should be required to step down from that immediately because even though I trust his integrity, it is a potential conflct of interest and a bad position for a person who has to be neutral to be in.


October 20, 2007

The Next Yankee Manager

Mitchell said it in the comments the other day and Andy and I have talked about it a lot recently.  You never want to be the guy who who follows the guy- you want to be the guy who follows the guy who followed the guy.  To put that into English, you don't want to be the guy who follows Torre. 

That is a very important point as the Yankees start their managerial search.  This is not the time to turn to Don Mattingly.  Mattingly is a God in the Yankees' universe and putting him in as manager now will only end badly.  The expectations are too high and if Mattingly follows Joe, I think there is a very good chance that things end up with Mattingly turning his back on the Yankees after being fired.  And to me, that is too high a price to pay. If I am the Yankees, i send Mattingly to AAA to manage for a year and then bring him back as bench coach in 2009.  Some seasoning would not be a bad thing and I think Don would be more than happy to agree to that situation if there was a plan to eventually make him the manager. 

And that is the tricky dance the Yankees will have to negotiate in this search.  The ideal situation was to give Torre two more years with the understanding that he retire after 2009 to some other position in the organization.  Since that won't happen, who could fill that slot and basically keep the seat warm for Mattingly while also developing some of the younger talent?

Obviously, Joe Girardi is out of this discussion, he wants to be a long-term manager.  That doesn't bother me because as much as I like Joe and admire the job he did in Florida, I have a lot of concerns with how he used his young pitchers.  Maybe it was the situation he was in down there, but Girardi abused Dontrelle Willis and didn't handle some of the other young pitchers very well.  He is not the guy who I want deciding how to use Hughes, Joba and Kennedy next season.

Larry Bowa would be an intriguing candidate and if Mattingly got the job I would have wanted him as bench coach, but according to this, he is headed out of town.   (notice who the pitching coach is in that story too)  That is a big loss, because Bowa was a great third base coach and he did a wonderful job with Cano. 

Assuming he is gone, there is still another coach who could fit that caretaker role, Tony Pena.  Yes, things did not end well the last time Pena was a manager, but look at his record.  Pena is the only guy to get a winning season out of the Royals since 1993.  He did it with Darrell May as his ace (remember May in 2005?) and while he had Carlos Beltran, he didn't have much else.  I think the guy is a pretty good manager and he knows New York.  Best of all, and this will sound very crass, he is expendable. Firing Tony Pena will not upset the Yankees' universe the way that firing Don Mattingly would.  Pena can be the bridge between two iicons and there is a decent chance he will be successful in doing so. 

So, Pena is my guy, and the good news is that he is on the interview list.   I don't expect him to get the job since the pressure will be on the team to come up with a big name, but I think he is the right choice.

Then again, maybe Torre and the Yankees' management wake up Monday morning and realize the mistake they have made.   Sadly, I don't see that happening.

 

October 19, 2007

Joe's Story

Joe gave a riviting, if not very insightful press conference today that left me feeling empty.  Empty because it became clear to me that this is a divorce that never should have happened.

Joe made it sound like he left not over money, but over a lack of support.  

“The terms of the contract were the probably the thing I had the toughest time with,” Torre said.  “The one year for one thing, the incentives for another thing.  I had been there 12 years and I didn’t think motivation was needed.  I felt pretty well renewed every year going after something and we knew exactly what was expected here.  I just didn’t think it was the right thing for me, I didn’t think it was the right thing for my players.”

He also made it clear that this process was not a negotiation:

“When I expressed my dissatisfaction with the length of contract and the um….And the length of contract for the reason I think you are all aware of.  It’s just starts when you are in the last year of a contract especially for this organization you know after you lose two or three or four games the questions are going to come up again.  And again, it’s tough when you have to answer those questions, but you certainly understand they are going to be asked..  And I explained that and the fact that the incentives, which to me I took as an insult.  You know we basically get to postseason and now all of a sudden we are satisfied with where we’ve gotten to. “

It will be interesting to see how we view October 18, 2007, when we look back at it in a few years.  The Yankees ran off four trips to the World Series after they fired Casey Stengel and there are certainly many reasons to think that this current team can continue to make the postseason.  But, there will be tremendous pressure on the next manager and I can't escape the feeling that both sides deserve blame in this situation.  Joe and the Yankees are both diminished today and I think both of them will have regrets going forward.  

But, go forward they must.  Thank you to Joe for a wonderful 12 years and good luck to him in the future, whatever he does.  Now, the Yankees have to get to work and first up is getting a manger.  We will discuss that further this weekend.   

October 18, 2007

Joe Gives Yankees Bronx Cheer

Joe Torre said "no thanks" to the Yankees offer of a contract extension.  According to ESPN, Torre turned down a 1 year, $5 deal with incentives that could have boosted the total to $8m based on postseason success.

More soon.

UPDATE 4:25pm- The deal was for a base salary of $5-million with an additional $1-million bonus paid for each round of the playoffs the Yankees reached.  In addition, there was a team option for 2009 that vested if the Yankees made the World Series in 2008 at $8-million.  

Personally, I am shocked by this.  I think you have to say the Yankees made a fair offer.  Yes, he would take a pay cut, but he would still be the highest-paid manager in the game and have an opporunity to earn even more in 2008 than he did in 2007.  Maybe Joe was tired of all the bs, maybe he just had enough, but this is an awful way for his legacy to end and knowing how Steinbrenner works, I fully expect some coach or player to be wearing number six next February.

I need to figure out my feelings on a deeper level, but I am initially angry with Joe for doing this.  But, I want to hear from him and hear his side of the story before I really make up my mind.  Needless to say, the offseason is off to about as bad a start as possible.