Categories

« A Big Trade | Main | Hurry Up and Wait »

A New Way Of Doing Business In The Bronx?

Hank is not his father's son. Yes, he talks like George once did and he looks a lot like him, but there is a huge difference. If George was in charge, Johan Santana would be a Yankee right now.

It is almost unbelievable to think that this report is true, but if is it, the Yankees could have had Santana for Hughes, Cabrera, Hilligoss and Marquez. That is a steal and the fact that the Yankees didn't do it knowing that it would mean that the Red Sox would get Santana tells you that there is a new order being established in the Bronx.

You can draw two conclusions from this.

First, even the Yankees have a budget. Santana would have cost a ton of money while opening up a hole in center. The Yankees could have simply written a couple of checks to cover up the holes and gone on their merry way, but they didn't. This despite knowing that $65 million comes off the payroll at the end of '08 and a new stadium opening up means lots of new revenue streams.

The other is that the Yankees finally, finally, finally, finally have learned their lesson, you can't just bring people into New York and expect them to star. Santana is a wonderful pitcher, but he is a wonderful pitcher in Minnesota. I mean no disrespect to Minnesota, it's a wonderful place and I have always loved visiting it, but it is not New York. That's not a bad thing, but until you have come and played in New York and had to deal with the media, you just don't know what you are in for. Think of all the papers who cover the Yankees with a beat writer. Off the top of my head, I can name eight and then throw in two 24 sports radio stations with their reporters who cover the team and the tv and you get a circus. If you screw up in New York, you face 15 microphones in your face that night asking you why. Will Santana be able to handle that? Nobody knows, Randy Johnson certainly wasn't able to. And I am not suggesting that the media was the reason Johnson bombed in New York, that was more age than anything. But, the media didn't help.

Santana could come here and thrive under the lights, he could wilt. He probably still would be a very good pitcher, but the Yankees are not looking for good, they want great. Consider how Phil Hughes has been brought through the organization. The non-roster invites to camp, traveling with the team at the end of 2006 to see how things worked. The Yankees have tried to indoctrinate him a little at a time to the ways of New York. It looked like it had worked pretty well in Game 3 of the ALDS when Hughes showed he was ready to step into the spotlight. Brian Cashman knows Hughes, he knows everything about him and he is willing to stake his career on what Hughes does in 2008. The easy thing for Brian to do would have been to make the trade. There is an old adage for mutual fund managers about how .obody gets fired for buying IBM. The implication being that IBM is the smart and safe choice. That was Santana, but Cashman didn't bite and his conviction should be admired.

Whatever the reason, the Yankees have taken a big risk. Put Santana atop the Boston rotation and you have a dominant 1-2 combination that is unparalleled in baseball. Think about having to face Beckett and Santana or Santana and Beckett in the playoffs, not a pretty thought. But, the Yankees obviously believe that Hughes and Joba will at least approach that level. They are willing to bet their ability to compete with Boston on the arms of some young pitchers and the potential of their farm system. If they are wrong, expect plenty of parades in Boston. That is a bold move, but as a fan, I could not be happier.

Comments

Mentally, Santana is as good as they come. I think he would do a very, very good job in New York -- as long as he's healthy. Take a look at his playoff record -- unless he's pitching on overly short rest, he's lights out. He can pitch under pressure.

But, I am a little queasy about giving away lots of young talent (to be replaced by highly expensive old talent) and spending $125 million on a guy who might blow out his arm in a year or two.

Also, Santana had a good year by any mortal's standard, but not a very good year by his standards. He's developed a real gopher-ball problem. You should appreciate that the Metrodome has very long dimensions to left and is highly favorable to lefty pitchers. He doens't get a huge break going from the Metrodome to Yankee Stadium. And if the Sox pick him up, look for some real problems with the green monster.

Usually, Santana gets off to a slow start, but he is completely lights out and as good as Pedro Martinez in his prime over the course of the second half of the season. That was not the case in 2007. I'm a little worried that he's starting to wear down.

Of course, I said the same thing about Pedro and he seemed to hold up awfully well when the went to the Red Sox.

On balance, I would not do the deal. When you get done with luxury taxes, replacing the young players, and paying Santana, you are overpaying and taking a huge risk.

I'll chime in to say that I too am happy that we're passing on Johan at the stated levels of the deal/demands.

Just remember: Beckett may go back to his 2K6 form and Johan looked pretty hittable at the end of 2K7. These guys are sometimes fragile. Buyer Beware.

Also, remember that Pappi and Manny ain't getting any younger, nor are Wakefield, Timlin, Schilling and Buchholz may pull a Pedro with his fatigued shoulder. The laws of physics hold in Boston just as well as they do in the Bronx. Let's also remember that we were the best team in baseball for the last 4 months of the season and life might have been different if we had some better midge-repellant avilable to us in OH.

Let's hope Cash stays the current course and then see what it looks like after then next 162 games.

Mitchell and Corey, good points and I think the sticking point for all of us is the amount of money they would need to spend on Santana and the length of the deal. Pitchers are fragile like you said Mitchell and there is always the chance someone breaks down.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.yankeesredsox.com/blog-mt/mt-tb.fcgi/279


Hosting by Yahoo!