Is This The Lineup?

Tanaka makes his last start of the spring today and the Yankees are using a lineup that could be their opening day lineup. It is:

Gardner-L
Sanchez-R
Bird-L
Holliday-R
Ellsbury-L
Castro-R
Headley-S
Hicks-S
Torreyes-R

It’s perfectly balanced between lefties and righties and it splits Gardner and Ellsbury up. I suspect Didi would hit 5th and Llsbury would be lower, if he was healthy.

Interestingly, it doesn’t include Aaron Judge. That could be a sign, but Judge has done everything the Yankees could have hoped for this spring. His slash line is .321/.390/.509 and he has struck out 12 times in 53 AB’s. Normally, I would think that would get him the job, but the Yankees may want to give Hicks one last chance to play everyday. Judge or Hicks is one of the bigger decisions left in camp.

There are two other big ones.

1- The final two rotation spots. I think Severino has done enough things to earn one and that Jordan Montgomery will lock the other down with a good start on Thursday. He’s been really impressive in camp. That would kick Brian Mitchell to the pen most likely as Luis Cessna has already been sent down.

2- What the Yankees do with Chris Carter. He’s been terrible, hitting .128 with a single home run while striking out 25 times in 47 AB’s. With Bird showing no lingering rust and having a great spring, what role would Carter play? The smart thing would be to cut him loose and eat his $3-million, but the Yankees could go a different route. With three days off during their first seven games, they don’t need a 5th starter until probably April 15th. They could carry Carter for that stretch instead of a 13th pitcher and see if he can help in any way. They would still have 7 arms in the pen as usual, just an extra bat on the bench.

We shall see, only five days until the season starts!