Buying Low Again

The Yankees clearly didn’t trust Rob Refsnyder or Dustin Ackley to play second base every day. That isn’t unusual for them, they tend to shy away from youth whenever they can.  What is unusual is that they didn’t do a knee-jerk veteran signing. Instead, they traded for a three-time All-Star who is only 25.

Starlin Castro will be the Yankees’ second baseman next year and for the three after that, since he is signed to an affordable four-year/$38-million deal. (There is a $16-million team option for 2020 the Yankees could also exercise.)

In exchange for Castro, the Yankees are sending Adam Warren and Brendan Ryan to the Cubs. That’s not a huge price for a three-time All-Star, so why am I titling the post “Buying Low”?

That’s because Castro isn’t the player he was when he signed an 8-year/$60-million deal with the Cubs. He no longer appears to have the 20-steal speed, and he has had two bad offensive seasons in his last three years. In addition, his defense at shortstop was bad last year.

But here is what the Yankees see. They see a guy who is one year removed from a .292/.339/.438 season. They see a guy who tore the cover off the ball in August and September last year after moving to second base full-time while playing good defense there. They see a guy who has been durable. And they see a guy who is actually a month younger than their current starting shortstop and is only a year older than Rob Refsnyder. And they see a guy who may have solved some off the field problems.

So, you can’t accuse the Yankees of abandoning their youth movement, or shelling out big bucks. Four years at $38-million doesn’t get you a decent starter in this market. (The impetus of this deal is the fact that the Cubs gave Zobrist 4/56 to take over second. That’s a Yankee move, or former one.)

Adam Warren was a nice piece, but he wasn’t a good starter and the Yankees should be able to fill the fourth arm in the bullpen spot fairly easily.

And Castro solves a roster problem for the Yankees. They can now put Ackley on the roster with no worries. He is their backup at second, left, and probably first. That’s an upgrade for sure. Castro can play short and probably third. If they don’t trade Gardner, they have Hicks to backup the outfield, another upgrade. They still need a backup catcher, but the bench could be quite versatile.