An Interesting Question

Rob Neyer asks when we will put another starting pitcher in the Hall of Fame?

It’s hard to make a case for Clemens ever getting there based on his vote totals. Maybe Schilling has a chance, but Mussina doesn’t seem to.

And if those guys don’t make it, who will make it? Jamie Moyer has lots of wins (269) but he had to pitch into his late 40’s to get them. Andy Pettitte has lots of wins, but PED issues. Roy Halliday doesn’t have a lot of wins (203) but he was brilliant for most of his career. Maybe he breaks the streak in 2019.

Beyond that, here is the list of active win leaders. Looking at it, we probably won’t see a 300-game winner again. Take any of these pitchers and give them 15 wins a season until they turn 40 and the only three who would be projected to make it are Sabathia, Felix and Kershaw. Sabathia isn’t going to get there, and as great as Felix and Kersahaw are, that is an enormous projection.


So it really is a great question with no apparent answer.