Your All-Time Line-Up

We haven’t yet arrived at Spring Training but baseball is around the corner.  That got me to thinking about the Red Sox line-up and that got me to think about the best line-up ever.

Let us know your best line-up ever.  Price is not an issue.  The players in your line-up need not be living.  And in a nod to baseball purists, perhaps things like personality, effort and other intangibles can be included.  After all, a team of Ty Cobbs might all be murdered by season’s end, a team of Pete Roses in trouble with a bookie and a team of  Barry Bonds unable to fit their heads through a door.

We are looking for the line-up order too.

Hers is my first crack at it and I’m using a DH:

1.) Rickey Henderson – DH – The best lead-off hitter of all time.  A blend perfect blend of on-base skill and speed.

2.) Rogers Hornsby – 2B – Hit .400 or more 3 times with a career 1.010 OPS.

3.) Ted Willams – LF – Not much of a fielder but you can hide that in left field at Fenway, but his hitting was otherworldly.

4.) Babe Ruth – RF – Best baseball player of all-time.

5.) Willie Mays – CF – Tough choice between Mays and Mantle, but I think the defense here is too much to ignore.

6.) Lou Gehrig – 1B – Impossible to get out and I realize it is insulting to him to have him bat 6th, but so be it.

7.) Mike Schmidt – 3B – A brilliant combo of power and fielding.

8.) Johny Bench – C – Not quite the hitter Mike Piazza was but 10 times the fielder, the only person to consider at catcher.

9.) Honus Wagner – SS – Ozzie Smith was considered here as his defense was better but offensively, no comparison.  I had to hit someone 9th.

Some interesting notes, it is very difficult to gauge defensive value with old-timey players as they used far different equipment and as a result their fielding percentages were almost always lower  when compared to modern players using modern equipment.  And the ability for defense to be evaluated using visual evidence is something not afforded older players, so reputation is playing a part here for me.

But getting past the fine print, how great would this line-up be?  Putting 2 lefties in Williams and Ruth back to back isn’t ideal, but hey, it’s Williams and Ruth and I think they’ll be just fine.  There are some defensive liabilities in this group, but the offense just cannot be overlooked.

What does your line-up look like?

 

 

Cut Him or Welcome Him

Two different stories in today’s papers with the same theme- the Yankees are rejecting A-Rod’s attempts to apologize and meet with the top brass. This is a stupid approach for the club to take.

I have said that I don’t think the Yankees should allow Alex to ever wear their uniform today. I still believe that they should cut him. But, if they are not going to cut him, they need to stop acting like five-year olds. Alex has behaved like a total ass, but he deserves some small amount of credit for wishing to meet with team officials and apologize for that. The Yankees gain nothing from preventing him from doing that. In fact it makes no sense at all.

The Yankees owe Alex $61-million for the remainder of his contract that much is clear. Barring a career-ending injury, they are going to have to pay that. So unless they are willing to cut him and swallow that hit, they should make nice with Alex and pray that he can give them some production in exchange for that money. They don’t have to do anything special to accommodate him, but would listening to him apologize really hurt them in any way?  And how will making it harder on him help them get a productive Alex this spring?

I get it, the Yankees are mad at Alex. Get in line, pretty much everyone is. He cheated, then he lied, and then tried to cover it up in a despicable fashion. Everyone knows all of that, but the Yankees have to decide if they want a chance at a return on that $61-million, or they simply want to throw a tantrum.

Back Where They Belong

The Yankees are heading back to Channel 11, WPIX next year for 20 games. I am thrilled by this.

It has been 16 years since the Yankees last appeared on Channel 11, and in the interim the channel became home to Mets games of all things. But from 1951 until the late 70’s, Channel 11 was the only place to watch the Yankees on TV. It was the channel I turned on as a six-year old on October 2nd, 1978, and watched Dent hit a big homer and Greg Nettles catch a huge pop-up. It was the channel that gave us Bill White and the Scooter calling games and showed us flashes of the GWB every game because Rizzuto was worried about beating the traffic.

It is also the channel that broadcasted Batman every afternoon along with the “Pix Game“, and the Yule Log every Christmas. (They still do the latter, and I put it on every Christmas morning.) In short, Channel 11 reminds me of my childhood, so excuse a 40-something guy for getting a bit nostalgic over this news.

Meet The New Boss…

Rob Manfred has made some committee decisions and he is not off to a strong start.

First, he has removed any owner who voted against him from the executive council. Hal Steinbrenner and others are on, John Henry and others are off. That seems like pretty blatant favoritism to me.

Second, he has appointed Fred Wilpon as head of the MLB Finance Committee. This one is even better because Wilpon was a pretty famous victim of Bernie Madoff. In that respect, he certainly had company. But Wilpon was sued by the trustee of Madoff”s victims for showing “willful blindness” to Madoff’s schemes. Wilpon eventually settled that claim for $162-million.

And the Mets also have reduced their payroll from $140-million to a projected $82-million this year. Considering they play in New York and reap the revenue benefits of that, should they really have the 22nd-biggest payroll in MLB?

But the guy who presided over the collapse of the payroll from $140-million to $82-million and was accused of being complacent in the Madoff scheme is now running MLB’s finance committee. Perhaps I celebrated the demise of Bud Selig too soon.

Pitch Clocks?

Apparently, the “wise” owners have decided to try pitch clocks this upcoming season at the AA and AAA levels.

I am not against the idea of a faster game. I wouldn’t mind it one bit, but one of the great things about baseball is the lack of a clock. Adding a clock to MLB is like putting a TV up in church to me.

If the owners really want to speed up the game, here are a few ways they can do it without adding an artificial clock.

1- Start calling strikes on balls above the waist. This would lead to fewer pitches in a game and shorter AB’s.

2- Cut down on the time between innings. This will never happen because it would reduce TV commercials, but if you took 45 seconds out of the break between each inning that would eliminate at least 12 minutes from the length of a game.

3- Call a strike if a batter steps out of the box after a pitch. This is a personal peeve of mine. Why do hitters need to readjust everything after every pitch even when they haven’t taken a swing?

4- Make replay an automatic process. Have someone in charge of reviewing calls who decides if a replay challenge is needed or not. Stop the stupid system of a manager stalling for time while he waits to see if the dugout tells him to make a challenge. The point of replay is to get the calls right, so why not make it automatic?

How about trying some of these ideas before bringing a clock to baseball?

 

Height Matters?

The Yankees made another trade today, getting Chris Martin from the Rockies for cash. Martin is 6’8″, which puts him in good company with the new Yankees’ pitching staff. The Yankees designated Gonzalez Germen, a pitcher they had acquired for cash from the Mets, to make room. Germen is only 6’2″.

Poor Brett Gardner. At 5’10”, he is the shortest Yankee and he gives up three inches to the Yankees shortest pitcher- Adam Warren. The Yankees have the makings of a basketball team with the quintet of Betances, Miller, Martin, Sabathia, and Pineda. Everyone is 6’7″ or 6’8″.

What does the height  mean? I have no clue, but Martin is another guy who throws heat. He has only had a brief cup of coffee in the majors, but he misses bats, a common theme among the Yankee bullpen. (Sidenote- Buster Olney ranked the Yankees bullpen second in MLB today behind the Royals) Realistically, Martin will head to AAA and wait for an injury to get his chance. But, it isn’t impossible that he beats out someone like Rogers for a roster spot.

38 days until pitchers and catchers.

 

An Interesting Point

Buster Olney (subscription required) points out that the Yankees could have a serious platoon advantage in the new AL East.

To summarize, the Yankees can trot out an all-lefty lineup now between switch-hitters and lefty bats. The AL East is projected to have 16-of-20 righty starters on teams other than the Yankees, much less than in recent years.

Add in the fact that Yankee Stadium clearly favors lefties, and it could be a solid advantage.

 

 

It’s Their DNA

Jon Heyman is reporting the Yankees have reached a deal with Stephen Drew. It sounds like a one-year deal for $5-million with an extra $1 or $2-million possible in incentives. I haven’t seen anything else about this, but Drew is a Boras client and Heyman has exceptional sources with Boras, so I would believe it.

Drew was terrible last year as we know, but a bounce back closer to his career levels is certainly not out of the question at the age of 32. The money is not a lot for the Yankees, but two things about this deal bother me.

1- All advanced metrics show that Drew wasn’t a very good second baseman last year. Now I am assuming he will play second, so that is a concern for me. (I don’t think they are trading Didi, but Cashman has been wheeling and dealing lately.) He had never played second before, so maybe he needed to learn the position, but it is something to worry about.

2- The Yankees had two young guys deserving of a shot to take over the position. Who knows if Refsnyder or Pirela would have worked out, but trying to beat Drew’s 2014 season wouldn’t take much. I am having a hard time seeing how this makes the club better.

And ultimately, wouldn’t it have been better to spend this money on starting pitcher?

An Interesting Question

Rob Neyer asks when we will put another starting pitcher in the Hall of Fame?

It’s hard to make a case for Clemens ever getting there based on his vote totals. Maybe Schilling has a chance, but Mussina doesn’t seem to.

And if those guys don’t make it, who will make it? Jamie Moyer has lots of wins (269) but he had to pitch into his late 40’s to get them. Andy Pettitte has lots of wins, but PED issues. Roy Halliday doesn’t have a lot of wins (203) but he was brilliant for most of his career. Maybe he breaks the streak in 2019.

Beyond that, here is the list of active win leaders. Looking at it, we probably won’t see a 300-game winner again. Take any of these pitchers and give them 15 wins a season until they turn 40 and the only three who would be projected to make it are Sabathia, Felix and Kershaw. Sabathia isn’t going to get there, and as great as Felix and Kersahaw are, that is an enormous projection.

 

So it really is a great question with no apparent answer.

The Votes Are In

The Hall of Fame has announced the class of 2015, and it contains four players. This is the biggest class since 1955, and the first time ever three pitchers were inducted at the same time.  The inductees, in order of votes received, are:

Randy Johnson-97.3%

Pedro Martinez-91.1%

John Smoltz-82.9%

Craig Biggio-82.7%

First off, congratulations to all four of them.

Mike Piazza almost cracked 70%, Jeff Bagwell was at 55.7%. Tim Raines 55%, Schilling 39.2%, Clemens 37.5,, and Bonds 36.8% rounded out the top-10.

Some observations

1- I am going to give the benefit of the doubt to the writers who left Johnson off the ballot and assume they used the vote for other worthy candidates.

2- Mike Mussina was in the 20’s, as was Allan Trammell. Trammell will be in his last year next year so it seems like he will never get in. I also don’t see how Schilling and Mussina’s combined vote totals don’t even equal Smoltz’s.

3- Next year will be interesting because only Griffey is a lock. That should get Piazza in.

4- This was Don Mattingly’s last year on the ballot. <sigh>

5- Want a good example of what PED’s did to the way the game is perceived? Look at Carlos Delgado, 473 career HR’s, and he didn’t even stay on the ballot for a second year.

6- Seeing guys like Troy Percival, Aaron Boone, Tom Gordon, and Darin Erstad get votes makes me crazy. This is why ballots should be made public.

7- Pedro is the first player elected born in the 1970’s. Pretty soon all the Hall of Famers will be younger than me- yuck.

8- Pedro made a point of saying “I did it clean” in his interview with MLB Network. He also said the toughest guy he ever faced was Edgar Martinez.