A Slight Upgrade At Third

The Yankees have acquired Chase Headley from the Padres for Yangervis Solarte and Rafael DePaula. Let’s dig into this.

What happened to Chase Headley? He hit 31 homers in 2012 and was fifth in the NL MVP race. Since that season he has hit a total of 20 homers. For his career, playing home games in San Diego has hurt him, his slugging percentage on the road is 72-points higher on the road than home, but interestingly, he has had a lower road slugging percentage in 2013 and 2014. A switch-hitter, in 2012 he destroyed RHP with a .906 OPS. That has declined to .740 in 2013 and .654 in 2014.

So why do I consider this an upgrade? Two things stick out about Headley. First, he is a very good defender and the Yankees could really use that on the infield. Secondly, he did have that year in 2012. Now he may not be that player anymore, but the Yankees have gotten overall production of .246/.312/.382 from third this year. Headley has the talent to achieve that, which would be an upgrade when you factor in his defense.

And consider what they gave up. Solarte is a fun player, but I think he got overexposed. There are very few six-year minor league free agents who become regulars. DePaula is the type of arm who could come back and haunt you, but he is stuck in A-ball at the age of 23. He was also originally signed in 2010, which should make him eligible for the Rule 5 draft after this season. Since the Yankees weren’t going to put him on the 40-man anytime soon, this makes sense. This is not surrendering the future in any way.

And it makes sense for the Padres. They were never going to offer Headley a qualifying offer, so at least they get something for him instead of seeing him leave as a free agent after the season. The interesting thing will be to see what happens if he plays well for the Yankees. Would they sign him to a deal and if they did, what would that mean for A-Rod? (Remember him?)

We shall see, but one thing worth remembering as we close in on the trade deadline- nobody reported anything about this deal being in the works. I don’t know how he does it, but remember that Brian Cashman, aka the Silent Assassin, moves in the shadows. Listen to trade rumors at your own risk!