19 Dec 2014
The word is the Yankees have packaged David Phelps and Martin Prado to Florida in exchange for Nathan Eovaldi, Garett Jones, and prospect Domingo German. This trade has three big ramifications.
1- Eovaldi is now part of the rotation. I like that. While his strikeout numbers have been mediocre, he has one of the best fastballs in the game and has a FIP much better than his ERA. He is an upgrade over Phelps and he is not eligible for free agency until 2018 Add in German, the sixth-ranked prospect in the Marlins system also with a big fastball as well, and you have two more young, power arms in the system.
2- Second base now appears to be a competition between Refsnyder and Pirela. I like that too. I wanted a younger and more athletic team, and the Yankees are starting to create that. I also was a bit worried about Prado’s defense at second.
3- Jones gives the Yankees a legitimate backup first baseman for the first time in a while (thank you!) and a very nice lefty bat for the bench. He mauls righty pitching, and can also play right field- where he would be a good platoon choice with Young.
And here’s a really interesting undercurrent of it all. Look at the bench for a minute. It’s full with Young, Jones, Ryan, and a backup catcher. This assumes Pirela or Refsnyder at second and A-Rod at DH. But the Yankees may have also made A-Rod even more of an afterthought. In his career, Jones has hit .267/.333/.479 vs. RHP. Young has hit .254/.357/.460 vs. LHP. Putting that platoon in right gives the Yankees a way to mitigate Beltran’s eroding defense. Putting Pirela on the bench gives you another Prado-type defender. Unless A-Rod hits, it is getting harder and harder to see where he can add value. Perhaps the Yankees have realized that $61-million is purely a sunk cost and forcing Alex onto a roster where he doesn’t fit is not going to help? There’s still plenty of time until the roster is finalized, but it will be very interesting to hear what Brian Cashman has to say about this trade when he holds his usual conference call.